Did hermione obliviate her parents in the book

From the power of certain magical items and spells to lily evans eyes, here are 10 plot holes from the deathly hallows movies. Immediately after the conclusion of the second wizarding war, hermione sought out her parents and returned their memories. Mrs granger and her husband gained a soninlaw when hermione married ron weasley. Sep 30, 2019 shes the incredible witch who had the guts to obliviate her own parents for their safety, but she also was a crap friend now and then who dissed other girls, including luna lovegood, so it stands to reason that shed be roasted on occasion. Sg her story continues in the cursed child play image. Theres a scene where she uses the spell obliviate in the movie on her parents. Here are ten things from harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 that wont make a lot of sense if you havent read the books. It was a temporary charm that was meant to be removed after the voldermort ordeal blew over. Hermione s hand shook as she pointed her wand at her mothers head.

Harry potter and the deathly hallows hermiones parents. Why did hermione say she hadnt performed a memory charm. That scene still makes no sense to me i get the pictures where it was hermione with her parents or something and now its just the parents but the pictures where she was the only person in them now its like hey, why did we frame this picture of the couch again. During the second wizarding war, hermione granger used a false memory spell on her parents. Anyone else tear up when hermione obliviates her parents. It is also not mentioned in the book anywhere about this too. Aug 01, 2012 why did hermione use the spell obliviate in harry potter and the deathly hallows. She reached into her bag and pulled out a small book. Hermione wipes her parents memories in hopes to protect them during the hunt for horcruxes. Resourceful, principled and brilliant, hermione jean granger is easily the brightest witch of her generation. Id always assumed because i thought her parents died, but was never for sure. Hermione tells him of her act where she secretly cast a false memory charm on both of her parents. What spell did hermione granger use to make her parents forget about her. Why did hermione used the obliviate memory charm to make.

In a 2004 interview with the bbc on world book day, j. Feb 22, 2016 so it seems based on the books that altered memories can be reversed where erased memories can not without severed damage betha jorkins. But as far as i remember it never wraps up what happened with hermiones parents. Did they ever go back to england or remember their daughter, or did hermione not do anything about question and answer in the harry potter club. After the two teens had told harrys godfather sirius what had been happening at hogwarts, all about the vile umbridge and her detentions and torture. In the book hermione simply made her parents think that they had no children and wanted to move to australia. She made them believe that they were called wendell and monica wilkins, a couple with a desire to go to australia and live there. Sep 21, 2019 however, there are still some moments that dont make much sense if you havent already read the book when watching the film. She made them think they wanted to move to australia and that they didnt have a daughter because she knew the. The two of them proceeded to have two children, rose and hugo. Jean granger turned around from the stove where she was busy trying to get dinner ready and surveyed her daughter with pursed lips.

She was their only child and, although they were a bit bemused by the oddities displayed by their daughter, they were known to be proud of her. In 1997, hermione modified her fathers memory so that he believed he was wendell wilkins, who didnt have a daughter and who wanted to live in australia, and did the same to her mother so that she believed she was monica wilkins. And how on top of that how harry had been forced by dumbledore to take occlumency lessons with snape, and what had gone on in the lessons. Hermione and her parents in diagon alley in front of flourish and blotts.

In fact, it adds to the back story and explains why she knows the theory. Ranking the biggest harry potter revelations since the. Hermione, prepping for her worldwide horcruxkilling tour with harry, must first obliviate her parents memories to keep them safe. Opening the book, hermione inserted the locks of her parents hair in separate sections and then put the book back in her bag. Read chapter 1 from the story obliviate dramione by mioneannabeth with 575 reads. At the beginning of the 7th book, hermione granger obliviates her parents memories of her and themselves and makes them think they want to move to australia. Since they were muggles, she wanted to keep them safe from voldemorts influence. She, along with ron weasley, is one of harry potters closest friends. May, 2018 as difficult as it was, hermione did what she needed to in order to keep her parents safe, and as soon as she could made things right with them again, she did. Seco she whispered softly pointed at her moms hair and a lock of her hair fell gently into hermiones hand.

In the book, hermione plants a false memory in her parents which she eventually reverses, but if you are watching the movie, you are essentially watching hermione remove herself from her parents lives forever. Why did hermione granger erase her parents memory in harry potter. Jun 30, 20 hermione put a memory charm on her parents to protect them from the death eaters. Why did hermione granger use obliviate on her parents answers. Why did hermione use the spell obliviate in harry potter. Here are 10 of our favorite memes that sum up hermione. I think hermione put the memory of her parents she pulled out of australia with a summoning charm in two dolls, then gave life to them and since then, these dolls are their parents. Her parents hadnt heard her come downstairs, she had made sure of that, but she was overcome with an overwhelming sense of sadness as she realised she wouldnt get to say goodbye. Obliviate and goodbye chapter 2, a harry potter fanfic.

In 1991, mrs granger and her husband were visited by a staff member from hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, who gave them the letter inviting their daughter to the school. Unfortunately, depending on your point of view it doesnt quite go as shed planned. Please check jks faqs before asking a question that may. Despite rowlings statement that the charm hermione used on her parents was not the same, in the part 1 film adaption, hermione uses the actual memory charm to eradicate her mother and fathers memories of her. Hermione used obliviate on her parents in the final film image. Harry potter and the deathly hallows hermione and her parents. Dec 21, 2019 one of the most heartbreaking things that happen sto hermione in the series is when she has to obliviate her own parents memories in order to keep them safe. Why does hermione say she hadnt used a memory charm before.

Nov 12, 2015 heres a case where i think the movie was different to the book neither better than the other just different. Or are her parents just clueless for the rest of their lives. However from the harry potter wiki page, i gather that hermione does meet her parents after voldemorts defeat and return their memories. Hermione obliviates her parents harry potter and the. Why did hermione granger erase her parents memory in harry. I would think that hermione would want her parents back to normal after all the battles and. Harry potter heartbreaking fan theory reveals sad twist. In the book, harry potter and the deathly hallows hermione reveals to harry that she has obliviated her parents from ever knowing her at a strategic story moment. She had to obliviate them because she didnt want them to get killed during the war, and made them want to move to australia and have new identities instead of being grangers. She made them think they were different people, who didnt have a daughter and who wanted to move to australia. Why did hermione granger obliviate her parents towards the. Unfortunately, depending on your point of view it doesnt quite go as shed planned obliviate is never enough, chapter 5 by joshlamont. Did hermione ever recover their memories and return to them after voldemort was defeated. Why did hermione erase her parents memory at the beginning of.

While its possible she meant her extended family, there may be a reason hermione didnt say. Why did hermione granger use obliviate on her parents. How did the sword of gryffindor end up in the lake. Rowling has said this was a different charm, which alters memories rather than removes them. What chapter in harry potter 7 has the scene where hermione. In chapter 9 of deathly hallows, just prior to erasing antonin dolohov and thorfinn rowle s memories, hermione says that she has never performed a memory charm before, despite having already altered her parents memories. Hermione was born to mr and mrs granger on 19 september, 1979. Jean granger turned around from the stove where she was busy trying to get dinner ready and surveyed her.

She made her parents forget her, forget harry and everything about magic, even forget who they are and that they had a daughter, so that in case voldemort wants to find her and. She is also muggleborn her parents were dentists ps12, and so is a living, breathing example of the fallacy of pureblood wizard supremacy. What spell did hermione granger use to make her parents. As difficult as it was, hermione did what she needed to in order to keep her parents safe, and as soon as she could made things right with them again, she did. Nor have i, said hermione, but i know the theorychapter 9 a place to hide. From what the book says, even though the movies wrongly used the erase memories spell obliviate for hermiones parents, she just altered her parents memories. Hermione obliviate s her parents harry potter and the. Hermione, at least, was shocked, as her parents presumably were, but was pleased. She was powerful enough to reverse any charm she put on them. Unfortunately, depending on your point of view it doesnt quite go as shed planned obliviate is never enough by joshlamont. The obliviate scene at the beginning of harry potter and the deathly hallows is an excellent scene that is about 23 minutes in length and could be analyzed for its cinematography.

When she goes to help harry hunt the horcrux, she doesnt want her parents to be a target, so she modifies their memories and sends them to australia. She did this in order to keep them safe incase the death eaters came after them. Hermione granger wanted to protect her parents and so made them forget who they were. I dont believe its directly addressed in the stories, but hermione indicates things about her parents substitute life, such as the fact that they dont have a daughter. Things you may not have noticed about hermione pottermore.

Obliviate charm however, completely vipes the memory, making it unrecoverable even by magic. When harry and ron first met hermione on the hogwarts express, she told them. What page did hermione granger put a memory charm on her. It begins with hermione using the obliviate spell on her parents, and everyone drinking the polyjuice potion to. However, it all still fits in as in the film hermione doesnt say she hasnt used it before. In the movies, hermione cast the spell obliviate on her parents, making them forget they ever had a daughter. She made her parents forget her, forget harry and everything about magic, even forget who they are and that they had a daughter, so that in. She probably looked up memory alterations to find the best way to protect her parents. Obliviate mum, hermione granger said, i have something to tell you and dad. May 15, 2018 during the second wizarding war, hermione granger used a false memory spell on her parents. Hermione s obliviate in a effort to protect her parents hermione cast a memory charm and erases herself from her parents memories.